A French politician has sparked headlines by suggesting the US should return the Statue of Liberty, a gift from France in 1886, claiming America no longer embodies the values it represents. Raphael Glucksmann, a member of the European Parliament, made the remarks during a speech to his left-wing party, Public Place, criticizing US foreign policy under former President Donald Trump. While the comments were largely symbolic, they highlight growing European concerns about America’s global role. The White House dismissed the idea, emphasizing the enduring alliance between the two nations.
Why the Statue of Liberty Matters
The Statue of Liberty, a symbol of freedom and democracy, was gifted by France to the US to commemorate the centennial of American independence. Designed by French sculptor Frédéric-Auguste Bartholdi, the statue was funded by the French people, while Americans financed its pedestal. Transported in 350 pieces, it was unveiled in New York Harbor on October 28, 1886. Today, it remains a UNESCO World Heritage Site and a cherished emblem of Franco-American friendship.
Glucksmann’s Critique of US Policy
In his speech, Glucksmann accused the US of abandoning its role as a global leader, citing former President Trump’s foreign policy decisions. He referenced Emma Lazarus’s famous poem on the statue’s pedestal, which speaks of welcoming “the huddled masses yearning to breathe free,” suggesting America has strayed from these ideals. While his call to “return” the statue was symbolic, it resonated with some Europeans critical of US leadership.
The White House quickly dismissed the remarks. Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt emphasized America’s historical role in defending France during both World Wars, stating, “It’s only because of the United States of America that the French are not speaking German right now.”
Could France Actually Reclaim the Statue?
Legally, the Statue of Liberty is US government property and a protected UNESCO World Heritage Site. Glucksmann himself acknowledged that reclaiming it is impossible, calling the idea a “wake-up call” rather than a serious demand. The statue’s cultural significance transcends borders, embodying universal values of freedom and democracy.
Franco-American Relations: A Complex History
While Glucksmann’s comments were provocative, they do not reflect the official stance of the French government. President Emmanuel Macron has sought to maintain a working relationship with US leaders, even while criticizing certain policies. For example, Macron has pushed back against US tariff hikes and expressed concerns about US support for Ukraine.
Historically, Franco-American relations have been marked by mutual support. France played a crucial role in aiding the US during its War of Independence, while the US helped liberate France from Nazi occupation during World War II. These shared experiences underscore the deep ties between the two nations.
What’s Next for the Statue of Liberty?
The Statue of Liberty will remain in New York Harbor, continuing to welcome millions of visitors each year. While Glucksmann’s remarks highlight ongoing debates about America’s global role, they also serve as a reminder of the statue’s enduring significance. As a symbol of hope and freedom, it belongs not just to the US or France, but to the world.
Raphael Glucksmann’s call to “return” the Statue of Liberty may have been tongue-in-cheek, but it underscores broader concerns about America’s evolving role on the global stage. While the statue isn’t going anywhere, the debate it has sparked serves as a reminder of the values it represents.
